In fairness, they’re both right. The iPad Pro 10.5 inch is overkill for most people who need a tablet for general browsing, email and other light activities. But then again, the Pro isn’t for those people.
For those people there are other iPads to choose from and for them, it could well be the only computer they need, other than their iPhones.
Despite the naysayers, I think this year we’ll start to see an end to the declining iPad sales as folks will be starting to upgrade and the new entry level iPad will gain greater traction. Additionally, the iPad Pro is a great option for creatives.
How you like them Apples!